For your Thanksgiving holiday meal on St. Thomas, if you’d rather not waste time and money shopping at stores that don’t have what you need or charge excessively more than the already high island grocery prices, this post is for you. If you like to have everything planned before arriving at your vacation destination, this post is for you. And if you’d prefer not to shop or cook at all, this post is also for you. Welcome to The Everything Guide to Thanksgiving on St. Thomas.

Grocery stores

Cost U Less

Your first stop for Thanksgiving essentials. Known for some of the best pricing on the island, Cost U Less carries nearly everything in bulk. If you’re traveling with a large group and want bulk snacks, bulk water, bulk cheese…bulk alcohol 😊, bulk anything, this is your store. They also have fresh vegetables, fruit, and protein. Chances are, you’ll be able to do 90% of your shopping here.

The Market

This is your next destination for the Thanksgiving odds and ends you couldn’t find at Cost U Less. While prices are a bit higher, The Market carries smaller, more manageable sizes for certain items. Don’t want to buy a double pack of 28 oz ketchup? You can find a more manageable 16oz bottle here. Both Cost U Less and The Market stock frozen turkeys for your Thanksgiving feast.

Moe’s or Fruit Bowl

For those hard-to-find specialty Thanksgiving items, head to Moe’s or Fruit Bowl. Both of these stores are pricier than the aforementioned on most items. But if you are looking for gluten-free, vegan, or any kind of specialty item, these stores might have them.

Moe’s has four convenient locations around the island, Red Hook, Havensite, downtown, and north side. Fruit Bowl, located near Havensite, is a favorite for fresh produce and unique ingredients.

Alternatives to Grocery Shopping

Hiring a Provisioner

If you prefer a home-cooked Thanksgiving meal but dread navigating multiple stores—and the inevitable shortages of key Thanksgiving ingredients—hiring a provisioner is a lifesaver. I’m not exaggerating when I say that grocery shopping for Thanksgiving and holiday meals can require several days and numerous stores. With everyone shopping for the same items around the same time, you can find yourself driving around to multiple stores looking for key ingredients like heavy cream, sweet potatoes, green beans, and other Thanksgiving essentials. If you submit your requests early enough, they can try to purchase popular Thanksgiving items before they sell out.

Hiring a Private Chef

For the ultimate holiday Thanksgiving indulgence, consider hiring a private chef—but don’t wait too long; they book up quickly, especially during the Thanksgiving holiday season. Companies like Caribbean Concierge can connect you with the best chefs on the island, offering everything from fully catered meals to convenient and affordable Thanksgiving holiday drop-off options.

This option is the ultimate in relaxation, convenience, and taste! You don’t have to deal with the madness of the stores, preparing the Thanksgiving meal, or the dreaded clean up. Just sit back, relax, and enjoy someone catering to you for once. Some chefs even offer drop off Thanksgiving holiday meals, which can give you the private chef experience at a more affordable price.

Restaurants!

For a worry-free Thanksgiving, reserve a table at one of St. Thomas’s numerous restaurants. Many restaurants will offer their take on a traditional Thanksgiving spread. Keep in mind, some will require you to preorder ahead of time. Deciding ahead of time where you want to go for Thanksgiving Day will help you avoid disappointment.